Choosing an idea
Should I build my app if something similar already exists?
Lumos · Updated
You can still investigate the idea. An existing app gives you something concrete to compare with how people work today. Find out whether a particular group still has a difficulty you could help with, and what would make changing tools worthwhile.
Try the existing product yourself. Pick the task your intended user needs to complete and follow it from beginning to end. Note the price, who it appears to serve, and any difficulty you actually encounter. Keep your preferences separate from problems users have reported.
Look for a reason someone would switch
Talk to people using the existing solution. Ask what works well, what they work around, and whether they've tried alternatives. Their answer may be that they're happy with it.
A useful difference could be a simpler task for a particular kind of user, or support for a workflow the existing product handles poorly. Adding more features creates more work to build and maintain. Check whether the difference matters before making it your plan.
The US Small Business Administration's competitive-analysis guidance covers alternatives, pricing, and competitors' strengths and weaknesses. Include manual workarounds in your comparison too.
If you find a specific unmet need, test a small version with the people who described it. If everyone you reach is satisfied and switching would add work, reconsider the problem or audience. Competition alone doesn't establish demand for your version.
In the Builders Handbook
Finding problems starts with what someone struggles to do. Are we solving the right problem? helps you question your first explanation.